It looks much better then the PotC game by many leagues. The game itself is a little clumsy with sailing if you ever played Sid Meier's but walking around makes it unique in comparison.
I'm sure it's a lot more fun then I'm making is sound but as a NOOB I still don't really know what I'm doing.
Compared to other online games, I think it's a little pricey for a monthly fee ($15) but not higher then any other game that's relatively new.
This is one of Joe Pyrats ships. I'm posting it so you can see that the graphics look really good.