Playing devil's advocate here.......
But as seen in other discussions in Pirate Pop, Interactives are gaining speed. How do you think the cannibal scene will play out in the Interactives? A nice disclaimer (come on Disney Lawyers, you know what those are) will play nicely into soothing everyone.
A rolling marquee along the bottom of the screen, while Jack is being rotated on the spit, proclaiming "Historically, Caribs were not cannibals. A creative license was used in portraying this story."
Gosh, even at the end of the movie, the disclaimer would be funny.