Foxe-
Yes I agree with you, there is no proof for widespread evidence of boot wearing in the GAoP.
I don’t agree with you about Logic though, that’s to speculative, what is one persons Logic is not always the next. Everyone’s reality is relative.
Yes I agree with you that there is a huge amount of evidence of other footwear.
GOF-
I agree with you also, that the boot was a tool, a piece of gear. Also what you said about the weather, it being cold. That’s why, in my opinion, I would prefer to wear something tall and waterproof on my leg to keep them warm and dry. Loose enough, for mobility and have the same sole as a shoe to retain traction. As the pictures depicted.
On an individual persona level, boots could be very authentic, but going by pictures, as a group they could lower the level of authenticity as a whole.
I to have sent the pictures, to the curator of the museum from which they came.