While I'm very new to going on the account, I am not new to reenacting. I spent twelve years doing an American civil war impression. I recall the often violent discussion of the pure and those that just didn't know any better, and i found that those that are the most boistrous and critical are usually the ones that have read only one source for their information and do not yet understand the attempt of authors to represent their opinion as they only source of true history.
I have found that people attempting to learn the history behind their impression are better dealt with in a compassionate and learning environment. No one likes to be chastized, especially by an arrogant stranger, for what they've worked very hard to do. Education and guidance are the key to having a successful reenactment group.
I'm sure that I will make several mistakes along the way in my attempt to authentically portray the brotherhood, and may even fall flat on my face. But I will try to be as authentic as my sources teach me and my pocketbook allow. Hopefully this reenactment community will be patient with me and a few knowledgable souls will help me along the way.
Just one "newbie's "opinion
Jack