Jump to content

Hot Coals...


ThomasBlackthorne

Recommended Posts

I just finished watching Captain Blood for the first time, and I was wondering about something.

Would firing hot coals in front of your ball even work?

Personally I think the coals would be destroyed from either the force of the blast or the ball itself. I don't think that they would prove to be a good accessory to your regular shot...

Anyone care to shed some light on this for me?

:D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In theory it could be done at very close ranges of fire ...dry wadding then wet wadding would have been put down the barrel to keep the coals from igniting the linen bag that held the charge ...the bag pricked with the cannoneer's brass pick and fired almost immediately upon loading the coals ....like with hot shot on a wooden vessel it was extremely risky ....whether it was actually done or not is hard to prove, but it made good movie action 70 years ago!!!

Edited by callenish gunner
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In theory it could be done at very close ranges of fire ...dry wadding then wet wadding would have been put down the barrel to keep the coals from igniting the linen bag that held the charge ...the bag pricked with the cannoneer's brass pick and fired almost immediately upon loading the coals ....like with hot shot on a wooden vessel it was extremely risky ....whether it was actually done or not is hard to prove, but it made good movie action 70 years ago!!!

Hot coals are likely a screenwriter's fantasy, however the use of hot shot was an actual fact.

>>>> Cascabel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The hot shot that Cascabel speaks of are regular cannon balls heated red hot in a furnace. These were most often used against ships from shore batteries as it requires some time and quite a furnace to heat a solid cast iron ball to red hot. Still, if you could load those into a cannon I don't see why coal could not be used like flaming grapeshot at extremely close ranges. This of course would not be charcoal, which would turn to powder on discharge, but bituminous quarried variety coal, basically flaming rocks. I found it interesting that the moviemakers actually had a special tool to load the cannon. Now to find a reference...

Edited by Captain Jim

3ff66f1f.jpg

My occupational hazard bein' my occupation's just not around...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that hot coals would not work (per the previous dust factor mentioned), but if they did a hot shot I do not see why they couldn't do a "raisin" shot (heated grape shot) as this would have been easier to heat than the Hot shot I would expect.

Did anyone see the Myth Busters' Pirate special in whch they tried different ammunition in the cannons?

Captain Justin Kase

Captain of the Dread Pyrate Ship SeaMonkey

Beloved of Anya Kase

Also Known As Silverback, The Naughty Bard

Quixotic Pyrate of the Desert Seas

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that hot coals would not work (per the previous dust factor mentioned), but if they did a hot shot I do not see why they couldn't do a "raisin" shot (heated grape shot) as this would have been easier to heat than the Hot shot I would expect.

Did anyone see the Myth Busters' Pirate special in whch they tried different ammunition in the cannons?

If it heats up fast, it cools down fast. Also the loading process is critical to your own ship. Mythbuster's treatment of the splinter effect of ships guns is deeply flawed and ,unfortunately , is one of their less thought out episodes. Land gunners don't always know what they are talking about when it comes to the tall ships.

the further away from Scotland ye roam, the more Scottish ye become

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Exactly correct, gunner Gordon. The idea of large hot shot is so that even with a couple of buckets of water poured over it, the mass retains enough heat to still set planking on fire. If you look at hot shot furnaces (there's a nice one at Fort Niagara and another at Castillo San Marcos) they are made for 18 pounders. Small shot just would not have the same effect. As far as putting it in a pistol barrel, the barrel itself would trransfer heat, and having enough damp wadding to isolate the coals would probably dampen your powder to the point it would not fire. Either way, its a pointless excersize.

The Mythbusters show was indeed badly flawed. I've been to Fort Nelson and seen the actual ship's side they recreated to test the Mary Rose cannon. 3 foot splinters, 2-3 inches thick. If you can find a copy of the show they did on that, it is far more accurate. Also, considering that the splintering effect is written up in all the period gunnery manuals, do we really think they were joking about this?

Hawkyns

Cannon add dignity to what otherwise would be merely an ugly brawl

I do what I do for my own reasons.

I do not require anyone to follow me.

I do not require society's approval for my actions or beliefs.

if I am to be judged, let me be judged in the pure light of history, not the harsh glare of modern trends.

rod_21.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Erie Maritime Museum also has a fantastic ACCURATE depiction of the damage shot does to a ship. They developed an authentic replica of the U.S. Brig Lawrence’s hull, and then using two of Niagara’s carronades, they fired fifty-three rounds of 12, 24 and 32 pound cannon balls as well as grape and canister shot.

You can read more about it here: Erei Maritime Museum

And pics of the museum and of the displayed shot hull: Photos

Captain Duncan McGuyver

Crew Of The Vigilant

Baltimore Maryland Based

17th & 18th Century Naval Living History

Crew Of The Vigilant

The Juryrig

MDRF Based Social & Renfaire Crew

The Juryrig

Port Tortuga

A Piracy based Pennsic household

B09 Block, The Highlands (Up Hill & Left)

Port Tortuga

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that hot coals would not work (per the previous dust factor mentioned), but if they did a hot shot I do not see why they couldn't do a "raisin" shot (heated grape shot) as this would have been easier to heat than the Hot shot I would expect.

Did anyone see the Myth Busters' Pirate special in whch they tried different ammunition in the cannons?

If it heats up fast, it cools down fast. Also the loading process is critical to your own ship. Mythbuster's treatment of the splinter effect of ships guns is deeply flawed and ,unfortunately , is one of their less thought out episodes. Land gunners don't always know what they are talking about when it comes to the tall ships.

I like the MythBusters and agree that sometimes their testing and research is not enough. The episode in which they tested a sword breaking and called it Busted was greatly inaccurate. I have been recreating Medieval times for 17 years and have seen my fair share of blades breaking on each other, shields, armor, etc.

I need to take a road trip to these maritime museums to see all this cool stuff I read about on these boards. I think I will try to hit the San Diego Maritime Musem within the year.

Captain Justin Kase

Captain of the Dread Pyrate Ship SeaMonkey

Beloved of Anya Kase

Also Known As Silverback, The Naughty Bard

Quixotic Pyrate of the Desert Seas

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

Watching Captain Blood I thought about that scene as well and have a different thought on it. The coals would provide almost no back pressure and would be next to impossible to ram due to the charge behind. However, have we been neglect in thinking that perhaps they were just put into the end of the muzzle of an already loaded cannon? With a ball between the charge and coals I doubt there would be nearly as much of a chance of an accidental discharge. Of course I believe there would be little to no effect.

id.jpg
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Watching Captain Blood I thought about that scene as well and have a different thought on it. The coals would provide almost no back pressure and would be next to impossible to ram due to the charge behind. However, have we been neglect in thinking that perhaps they were just put into the end of the muzzle of an already loaded cannon? With a ball between the charge and coals I doubt there would be nearly as much of a chance of an accidental discharge. Of course I believe there would be little to no effect.

You could get them to go out of the barrel but you would be hard-pressed to hit anything with them. The coals would scatter every which way. You might even set your own ship on fire.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that hot coals would not work (per the previous dust factor mentioned), but if they did a hot shot I do not see why they couldn't do a "raisin" shot (heated grape shot) as this would have been easier to heat than the Hot shot I would expect.

Did anyone see the Myth Busters' Pirate special in whch they tried different ammunition in the cannons?

If it heats up fast, it cools down fast. Also the loading process is critical to your own ship. Mythbuster's treatment of the splinter effect of ships guns is deeply flawed and ,unfortunately , is one of their less thought out episodes. Land gunners don't always know what they are talking about when it comes to the tall ships.

I like the MythBusters and agree that sometimes their testing and research is not enough. The episode in which they tested a sword breaking and called it Busted was greatly inaccurate. I have been recreating Medieval times for 17 years and have seen my fair share of blades breaking on each other, shields, armor, etc.

I need to take a road trip to these maritime museums to see all this cool stuff I read about on these boards. I think I will try to hit the San Diego Maritime Musem within the year.

The Mythbusters sword-breaking episode was one of their worst. They were using the strict definition that one sword had to cut another. Just breaking it wasn't enough. They also propagated the idea that you only parry with the flat of the blade. You have to go back to 15th century two-handed swords before you find anyone doing that. The later parries just don't work unless you use the edge.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

;) Interesting, most fictional writing I've read on the RN from approximately 1750 through 1830 always had the galley fires doused at beat to quarters. I would guess that the writers had come up with that piece of information some where. Only certain lanterns and slow matches were lit. dry.gif

Jas. Hook ;)

"Born on an island, live on an island... the sea has always been in my blood." Jas. Hook

"You can't direct the wind . . . but . . . you can adjust the sails."

"Don't eat the chickens with writing on their beaks." Governor Sawney

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
&ev=PageView&cd%5Bitem_id%5D=15313&cd%5Bitem_name%5D=Hot+Coals...&cd%5Bitem_type%5D=topic&cd%5Bcategory_name%5D=Armory"/>