This is going to be a Looooong post... sorry.
Instead of stating "Renn Faire pirate" vs. "Authentic Pirate", I'll just list what I have....My pirate garb is a continuing project, but what I wear right now is...
a pair of Civil War brogans, with rubber soles glued on (they wore through the soles, so I fixed them.Not period, but they work untill I get a pair of straight lasted shoes.
an very old pair of grey wool ski socks, with cloth garters (need the garters or they fall down...)
black wool kinda slops with a "French fly" and patches... not an authentic cut, but I only had so much wool to make them outta.
cotton period cut shirt, very distressed with tea and india ink.... I'm working on a hand sewn linen shirt, but it's a pile of rectangles right now....
brown heavy cotton flaired skirt coat, with black trim (and when they arive... 60 big brass buttons)
a heavy leather baldrick, with a holster on the front, and boarding axe sheath on the back... not period, but looks "cool"
a black cavalier hat with black plumes a sculpy skull , and sculpy skull beads on one side. Not at all period but fun...
I also carry a .58 Enfield musket... WAY outta period, but it makes a loud "Boom" when we fire at other ships...
Something I'm starting to work on is more period pirate garb.... After playing on the Royaliste, the above garb is very impractical... for playing in a parade, it works great, and fits peoples idea of what a pirate looked like.
From what I can figure, period garb would be... lose canvas pants, chackered drop shoulder shirt, short wool coat, and a canvas hat, painted to waterproof it. (and of course...weapons)
But How many people will recognize that as a pirate? I know it will be more practicle and period.
So I will have 2 sets of garb.... My Hollywood pirate, for parades and such, and a period pirate for playing on the Royaliste and such....
Both will be fun. I enjoy the Hollywood pirate, and enjoy trying to do authentic...
I will just post this for now... but there have been a buncha post that I'll reply to later.......