Jump to content

Black Beard on National Geo


Pirate Petee

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 63
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Woot, that was firkin' awesome. And thanks to DVR I can watch it again and again and again. Who's te say the devil does not exist?

THIS CABIN-LAD'S GROWN HAGGARD, SO IN THE POT HE GOES AND FROM HIS SKIN WE'LL MAKE A LITTLE DRUM TO BEAT AS WE FIRE HUMAN HEADS FROM CANNONS AT OUR FOES. AND SET THE SEAS ABLAZE WITH BURNING RUM.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It was awesome. Not as accurate as National Geographic would have us believe, but still awesome. I'm just thankful that at last...AT LONG LAST we have scenes of pirates actually committing piracy. The actors did a helluva good job, especially Israel Hands' stoic wisdom. The guy doing Charles Vane in the beginning was great too.

Here's my nitpicks:

1. I don't think they could have picked a location that looks LESS like North Carolina than Malta....what were they thinking there? :ph34r: Also noticed 90% of the land scenes were shot in the same stone tunnel.

And I've been inside the Williamsburg gaol....consisting of small above ground wooden cells, nothing remotely like the cavernous dungeon on the show.

2. Would have been nice to show the infamous "sinking" of the QAR, or Teach lighting the stinkpots in the hold. And Stede Bonnet was noticeably absent. I know they only had 2 hours, but those are some pretty major details to leave out of "the most accurate dramatization of Blackbeard ever seen on television".

3. Did they REALLY have to give Israel the Jack Sparrow "baubles, bangles and beads" look in his hair? :huh:

4. Wish they hadn't tried to stuff the extra pirate lore in there, with the "code" stuff, the French girl in disguise, the earrings, etc.

Overall I give them massive kudos for what is certainly the coolest pirate footage/show/reenactment I've ever seen on big or small screen.

4 Skulls!! :D:ph34r::DB)

Btw, is it just me or did they use the same sloop for all the sloops featured, then just splice 'em together digitally? I tivoed it so I'll have to recheck. Heck I'll be watching this alot, so much of it is so beautiful!

newbannersigtar0db.gif
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought it was pretty good. They did a lot of things really well, but definitely could have improved some areas. In particular, I didn't like the way they chopped it up - 8 minutes of show, 3 minutes of commercials (I timed it.) You just start getting back into the story and you're yanked out of it for the SAME commercials over and over again. I also agree that there were elements that they didn't have to include. The costuming was terrific, though - the pirates were nicely grimy.

And yeah, it looks like they just had one, maybe two boat interiors - the exterior long shots were all CGI.

RHJMap.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It was an interesting show, but I agree about the commercials. How many times do I have to see the bike change styles at the click of a mouse? (Ok, I get it - at least show us a different commercial about the bike.) Also, why did they cut Bonnet out? Maybe they didn't have a ship to represent him. Maybe they wanted to be able to get more commercials in. (Maybe I'm being cynical.)

I was pleased to see that they didn't use extra sound effects for the guns. There were several nods to the Hollywood characterization of pirates, though. Beads, earrings, firing pistols into the air (Who would do that with a gun that took so long to reload?) and so on.

Oh...Frenchie? Where did that character come from? I don't recall any historical reference to such a person. Is there a book I should have read?

Did anyone else think that he was sort of channeling Rush playing Barbarossa some of the time? (Of course, Rush's character was based more than a little on Blackbeard, so I guess that's fair.)

For those of you who missed it, it will probably be repeated several times throughout the coming month. Cable stations usually do that.

"You're supposed to be dead!"

"Am I not?"

gallery_1929_23_24448.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I saw in the trailer, that Blackbeard wore bucket boots... :P

:P

I hope they release it soon, on DVD. I don't get the National Geographic Channel, either. :P

Drunken_Parrot_Bar_Sign.jpg

You will be flogged. And God willing, come morning, you will be flogged some more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just happened upon it when we crawled into bed after the Irish Festival last night! I thought it was great (all except for the commercials. Wasn't the original promotion for cable tv supposed to be that it was commercial free?) Oh well, great movie - i'd watch it again :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes there were many things that weren't correct and many thing I'd love to see (the legendary party at Oroeekokee (sp?) , the skuttliing err I mean the running agorund of the QAR) but one thing I think was done right was the performance of Blackbeard by James Purfoy. It was an amazing perfomance.

No he wasn't channeling Rush as Barabossa he was making Balckbeard what he is usually was considered to be, a Bristol man. That was defiantely a Britstol accent. He made BB the smart, wiely badass he was. It was such a departure from what Purfoy normally does. Kudos to James Purfoy on a job well done. The rest of the cast was equally good.

The only other thing I I had problem with was BB's death scene. Instead of the beheading by highlander with a broadsword with BB saying, one of the best last lines in history "Well done lad" when the higlander first cut BB's neck. to which the higlander replied "If not well done, I'll do better". then he cuts BB's head off. Now that's a death scene! That whole grabbing Maynard and sying the bit about hidtory was incongruous.

I can't wait for the DVD. :)

Red Maria

The Soul of Indecency

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:huh::ph34r::ph34r:watched it twice through .....excellent film!!!!!

i will keep checking to see when it's out on dvd!!!

and since all we have to go on were the official accounts brought out at the trials it's possible that there could have been a female crew member who was otherwise undiscovered ....sure it was added for the effect

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just finished watching the taped show. Twas good...a bit inaccurate in parts...No mention of Hornigold--who gave Teach the QAR. Good models of the QAR & Bermuda sloops. Swell battle scenes. Will be watching it a few more times.

True, Joshua Red, the Ocracoke shoreline looked a bit rocky, and Bath did (& still does) not have a building so big.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love the dude that played Billy Bones in that movie, best hollywood pirate in my opinion.

I dunno there Petee me lad. I think Tyrone Powers' "The Black Swan" could give it a run for it's money.

THIS CABIN-LAD'S GROWN HAGGARD, SO IN THE POT HE GOES AND FROM HIS SKIN WE'LL MAKE A LITTLE DRUM TO BEAT AS WE FIRE HUMAN HEADS FROM CANNONS AT OUR FOES. AND SET THE SEAS ABLAZE WITH BURNING RUM.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No he wasn't channeling Rush as Barabossa he was making Balckbeard what he is usually was considered to be, a Bristol man. That was defiantely a Britstol accent.

It wasn't his accent I was referring to, it was that low growly thing he did with his throat occasionally. Sort of a pseudo "Arrrrr..." If I remember correctly, Rush created that specifically as some sort of balance between the fictional Hollywood pirate cry and reality. (I seem to remember reading or hearing that somewhere.)

"You're supposed to be dead!"

"Am I not?"

gallery_1929_23_24448.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...
&ev=PageView&cd%5Bitem_id%5D=6889&cd%5Bitem_name%5D=Black+Beard+on+National+Geo&cd%5Bitem_type%5D=topic&cd%5Bcategory_name%5D=Pyrate Pop"/>