greetings from sheppey
tis authentic question seems to stur up a hornets nest when it's mentioned!
from the point of view of a pirate who was once panto and has made personal strides to become authentic, i feel authentic should be a personal goal, not a demanded standard from other persons.
in our group we have those who are trying their best to authentic, those who prefer the hollywood look and those who wear cut down jeans and torn t-shirts and have no interest in authentic. all are welcome, but understand that certain events will require different levels of dress.
but because of the differing styles, i believe, that pirate re-enactment is not viewed by some other period re-enactors as 'proper' re-enactment. but i think that we need both authentic and hollywood. how i see it working is the hollywood style pirates catch the attention of the public, as that's what most public perceive pirates to look like, but draw them into the where the authentic style pirates are, so the public can be shown what pirates really looked like. but that is not saying hollywood can't show the public what piracy was like back then.
we've seen how the different groups from the brotherhood can work well together and put on a great event or show. so let's stop the bickering, put our heads together and show everyone that we can give the public everything they want.
macstink,
look forward to seeing you all on sheppey sometime soon
oh yeah, ed, what 'fantasy-type pirates doing some really stupidly dangerous things with cannons' are you talking about?