To open a can 'o worms...
I've noticed that most of the put-downs seem to be about garb. Wanting to be accurately is nice, but reenactment encompasses so much more than just dressing properly. I'd venture to say that my kit is, at best, 80% accurate. (I wear wool and linen on the outside, but I've gotta have my cotton undies... ) And two of my guns are cap locks. One of the reasons I'm not at 100% is because I've been too busy with the rest of the piratical reenactment requirements - sailing, firing black powder implementia (and by firing I mean doing more than making loud noises with 'em) and honing my skills with a variety of edged weapons, both theatrical and actual combat (thirty years at this.) And quite a bit of Ransom's and my reenactment time is actually spent on a ship. Patt has spent time learning the actual skills as well, which, from my observation, differentiates him from a lot of other folks who frequent Twill, who seem to mostly argue about how to dress properly (another reason I spend very little time in Twill.) I'm speaking as an observer who tries to live in both the accurate/fantasy reenactment worlds.