I liked the garb at barkertownsutlers.com
but I found the pieces to be plain for my taste. One of the things I like about Carlisles is the selction.. fancy or plain. I know some of you lads might want togo with plain, but I perfer a bit o' flurrish, a dandy is fine by me :) the ladies don't seem ta mind mates
But I do have garb for everyday piracy, and the shirt I have form Carlisle sis excellent... wiating on the Cailico Jack Pirate coat. I wrote them and the full coat is functional with the pockets and buttons, even on the cuffs. Plus they do try to create that histroric looks and feel with a duck material (a form of canvas) so it should hold up.
and El Pirata: yeah I would think their product pics would look clean and new, as for plain, well go with the Capaitan coat them :) .. but for a nice pirate stable coat the Calico is my go.. give it a few days in the stern sheets and rigging.. I am sure you will get a good weathered look, and their's should hold together.. seems solid made. I plan to hit mine with a waterproof sray since it is a canvas type material. Should hold well and give plenty of years. Wool would be better, but the fabric would cost more.