Baylus_Brooks

Member
  • Content count

    39
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Baylus_Brooks

  1. Quest for Blackbeard

    Apologies, milady! Quest for Blackbeard is now available in ebook formats: Lulu at $24.99: http://www.lulu.com/shop/baylus-c-brooks/quest-for-blackbeard-the-true-story-of-edward-thache-and-his-world/ebook/product-23093757.html Amazon Kindle at $24.99: https://www.amazon.com/Quest-Blackbeard-Story-Edward-Thache-ebook/dp/B06XPMPTVM/ref=tmm_kin_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr= Barnes & Noble Nook Book at 42% off right now for $14.49: http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/quest-for-blackbeard-baylus-c-brooks/1124659270?ean=9781365795923 Apple iTunes at $24.99: https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/quest-for-blackbeard/id1212991334?mt=11
  2. Quest for Blackbeard

    Hi ya lubbers, Just some bit of info on my book that was published last month. Google Books has a large preview to it especially the first couple hundred pages: Quest for Blackbeard: The True Story of Edward Thache and His World B&N page: http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/quest-for-blackbeard-baylus-c-brooks/1124659270?ean=9781365328213 Amazon page: https://www.amazon.com/dp/136532821X Printers site: http://www.lulu.com/shop/baylus-c-brooks/quest-for-blackbeard-the-true-story-of-edward-thache-and-his-world/paperback/product-22825800.html Author's Site: http://baylusbrooks.com/ Google Books site: https://books.google.com/books?id=v1veDAAAQBAJ&pg=PA511&dq=quest+for+blackbeard&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiF1d_l-tDOAhUHbiYKHXgUC5wQ6AEIHDAA#v=onepage&q=quest%20for%20blackbeard&f=false Baylus C. Brooks
  3. golden Age Pirate how truthful are the shown

    I am compiling transcriptions of pirate-related documents and making them available on my website at http://baylusbrooks.com in the "Pirate Library" section under "Reference Shelf." I find that reading such primary sources gives me a rich understanding of life in the Golden Age.. far and beyond what the popular and error-filled A General History can provide. These documents I have split between depositions, trials, papers, and letters. It is totally free... enjoy!
  4. Pirates were bloodthirsty criminals...

    Might I suggest that if you can't find what you want to be true, that it may not be true. I'm not one for the egalitarian aspect, but I certainly do not believe that pirates were predominantly bloodthirsty criminals. They were primarily businessmen. Profit was the main goal for the majority... not serial murder and torture, like Edward Low.
  5. What was a Jacobite?

    Ahoy, mates! I have written an article describing the complex political and historical context of what it meant to be a Jacobite. Please enjoy and parley on the points! http://bcbrooks.blogspot.com/2016/02/are-jacobites-criminals-or-just-loud.html Note the article from my book on Richard Tookerman of South Carolina that I referred to in the blog article: http://bcbrooks.blogspot.com/2015/12/south-carolinas-gentleman-pirate.html Baylus C. Brooks Candidate in Maritime Studies Program East Carolina University Professional Research Historian at Brooks Historical Amazon Author Page LinkedIn Profile
  6. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    1. Herriot might have been mad and he may have been coerced to damn Thache. There are way too many possibilities here... suppose the authorities discovered his lies. Suppose he crewmates felt brtrayed. 2. I'm saying that Thache gave up after the wreck... the crew went off to do whatever. The only evidence is for 20 crew and a handful of slaves. Howard left for Va with two. The crew split them up most likely... 3. Regardless of how you interpret it, archaeologists generally go higher than 50/50 on it being an accident. This might be statistical "babble" to you, but the math is sound. Do you believe that all non-primary sources are a 50/50 shot? If so, then the formula applies.
  7. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    1. immunity from prosecution 2. they left... the game was up... Capt. Brand's informant told him weeks after that 90 had already left for points northward and Thache was talking about sticking around, boasting about marrying (in the future) in Bath... and the informant said that there was a dispute among the pirates (Thache and Bonnet?). 3. http://baylusbrooks.com/QAR-R-09-02.pdf starts on page 15. More evidence to prove that it was an accident rather than intentional. Intent requires proof and Herriot and Pell both got immunity from prosecution by saying what the authorities wanted them to. That's not really proof... you might say that it's 50/50. Besides Herriot tried to escape anyway... that discredits his testimony. Let's not forget that Herriot had also just lost his ship Adventure. Was he mad?
  8. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    True... one piece of data alone proves nothing. That's what I was saying before, too. A 50% probability, after repeated occurrences, however, becomes 75% after two, 87.5% after three, and 93.8% after four... and so on. That is basic probability statistics... assuming that each occurrence had a 50% chance.
  9. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    If you're referring to David Moore, yes. But, there are quite a few more archaeologists working there who do not agree with him. In fact, I think he is alone on that opinion.
  10. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Thanks, Swashbuckler! I'll check out Maria Fusaro's book. Owing to this and similar arguments, I feel that we can't view pirates in 1715 quite like Rediker's William Fly in 1726. By that time, administrative opposition had worked against piracy in general and it had become a sea-bound independent guerrilla operation that probably did not reflect the pre-Rogers Bahamas Islands-Jamaica-Bermuda-Carolina operation. Everything went to hell, in other words.
  11. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    It's in the article, guys. This thread has played out. Thanks for playing.
  12. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Maybe he graduated from Spanish Town University with a degree in Buccaneering...
  13. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Ed, I never said that I couldn't be wrong. Just that my theory is better than most. The fitting scenario around the facts increases its probability. As for the comparison to gravity.. no. That was an example to illustrate how the preponderance of circumstantial evidence (the scenario again) added to the facts can bolster any case. It was not a direct comparison. I did not expect it to be taken so literally. As I said before, I will do my utmost to find that birth certificate for you, but would you settle for Lucretia bailing him out of jail? lol
  14. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    When these facts are taken independently, I would agree. No single source can ever be more than 50/50. Given that logic, the chances that a dropped ball will go down is 50/50. When it happens a lot, though... well? BTW, the Joseph Brooks from the Currituck area have been of long interest to me because they may relate to a branch of Brooks that we used to think were related. Many years ago, a DNA bomb went off that split these guys from us. It, too, is a circumstantial case, but it was fascinating to have some possible pirates in the cupboard, even if for only a short while. As for my case, it's good enough to encourage me to spend more money on getting to Jamaica, not just on beer. Like I said, there's a buttload of records that nobody has even looked at yet. I have to see those records... candy for the historian.
  15. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Don't forget that this man was a mariner and from the island best known for pirates. BTW, next time you hop the pond, come join me for a beer!
  16. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Ed, "Your whole theory hinges on Leslie being accurate." Does it, really? The actual records of Edward Thache are not suggestive, in the very least? My objective is to show these records. That is it. I have done that and I knew the consequences would be severe. I wrote an article attempting to interpret them. I do not have money riding on this theory. Writers and historians do not make fortunes. Others do... and have invested a great deal in it. I did not write a 27-page rebuttal. But, this thread is obviously no longer helpful. Somewhere, there's a beer with my name on it... thy name is Yeung-Ling!
  17. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Why would your Jamaican Blackbeard, Edward Thache, Jr., whose family you purport to have owned a large sugar plantation with slaves (even though you have provided no evidence of this “plantation”), then go to great trouble to capture slaves east of the Windward Islands in November 1717 from the French slave ship Concorde? And then why, at great risk, and by avoiding numerous opportunities to safely surrender to various colonial governors—including South Carolina’s Governor Johnson—did Edward Thache, Jr., of Jamaica, deliver those slaves to diminutive Bath, North Carolina, which is quite a far distance from the sea requiring navigation around dangerous shoals and serpentine sand reefs. And why did your Jamaican Blackbeard take those slaves to what was then a colonial backwater community well-documented to be economically depressed and with residents possessing little or no hard currency to purchase those slaves, especially when the pirates passed up other ports where those slaves would have fetched much higher prices? You assume that Thache meant to wreck his ship (QAR) in Beaufort Inlet and remain in NC. Your entire theory rests upon the supposition that Thache did not intend to continue pirating and that he did not stop in NC merely to careen his vessel... that this successful pirate intended to stay in this economically-depressed backwater. The evidence from my analysis of the Bonnet trial and from the archaeology, however, dispute this. http://bcbrooks.blogspot.com/2015/07/guilty-or-innocent-depositions-of.html BTW, the Thache deeds, wills and their slaves, Jim, Mary, Lucretia, Sabina, and more... provide substantial proof that the Thaches owned a plantation in Spanish Town. Are you saying that Thache cared for his supposed NC Beard family more than his own wealth? Careful, you may get flogged (pun intended) for this...
  18. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    I'm not asking you to believe anything except that Leslie could be an honest writer, using all of the sources that he has. The only section that he used that does NOT appear in any previous article is the section about Spanish Town and the parents. Where did that come from? It could have been personal experience, from an informant, maybe invented. But, there is certainly no reason to accuse Leslie of lying, simply because he does what any good journalist has ever done... and give all the information that he has available to him. "It's quite possible that Leslie is right about Blackbeard's parents, but it can't be relied on." Yes, but it need not be completely dismissed, either. That's MY point. Combined with other evidence, it begins to build a circumstantial case that increases the chances of success. In light of other evidence, maybe Leslie DID NOT LIE. As I said, gravity is still a theory, too. But, drop a ball and it usually falls down. All of these independent, circumstantial pieces eventually add up to some kind of evidence and cannot be dismissed when viewed together. You give my theory a 50/50 chance? Really? With all the evidence in the past leading to pirates in general focusing on Jamaica? Jennings, Barrow, Thache, Ashworth, Barnet, Parr, and so many of the 18th century's wealthy pirates have families on Jamaica. Buccaneers of the 17th century originally focused on Jamaica, almost since the day it was captured from the Spanish. Port Royal has become the quintessential home port of pirates and all the writers of the time knew this... including Leslie, but he chose the landlocked (not a port) capital of "Spanish Town." And, now, we have proof that an Edward Thache is from Jamaica, specifically Spanish Town (at least since boyhood)? And you still say it's 50/50? Come on... really? I still trust that gravity works, even though there is no grand unified theory yet to explain it. The chances are far better than 50% and you know it. They are certainly better than North Carolina. One thing I have noticed is a strong desire NOT to notice these things... to maintain the status quo and, in Blackbeard's case, to maintain the mystery. Isn't that what's happening here? We may be in danger of losing the mystery of our most iconic pirate.
  19. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Note that I don't believe Leslie used direct quotations, but paraphrased from the sources.
  20. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    This is the paragraph in question. I have colored different sections according to what I believe comes from different sources that Leslie compiled into this single paragraph. The first one I think is Johnson, but it's very general. The second one is the mystery shopper on Jamaica. The third one may be Johnson again. And the last section I believe comes from the Weekly Packet of 11 April 1719. It could be also Weekly Journal of the same date or other sources in BNL as well, March 2, 1719. They all say pretty much the same thing. At this time, the famous Edward Teach, commonly known by the Name of Black— beard, infested the American Seas. He was one of a most bloody Disposition, and cruel to Brutality. His Name became a Terror ; and some Governors being remiss in pursuing him, he almost put a Stop to the Trade of several of the Northern Colonies. He was born in Jamaica, of very creditable Parents ; his Mother is alive in Spanish-Town to this Day, and his Brother is at present Captain of the Train of Artillery. He was attacked by a Lieutenant of a Man of War, and was killed, after a very obstinate and bloody Fight. He took a Glass, and drank Damnation to them that gave or asked Quarter. His Head was carried to Virginia, and there fixed on a Pole. The last two sections may have both come from the BNL ref.
  21. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    No, I think he either knew them or had a report from someone who did. He then compiled his research together and wrote a paragraph in his book that reflected all sources... just the way any of us write now. He doesn't actually have to be lying in his book. I'm just saying that he maybe got conflicting information from different sources. Hasn't that ever happened to you? That's the scenario that I'm following to explain his reference. That's all. What was it to be a "nice family" in the early 18th century? Whatever it means, Leslie compared it relative to what he read about the notorious pirate Blackbeard. I think he was just surprised by possibly conflicting data.
  22. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    BTW, is my calling Edward Thache Jr. "Blackbeard" in my book any different than your calling Blackbeard "Edward Beard" in yours? I understood that once you established the extent of the possible relation, you didn't have to qualify EVERY SINGLE reference that you made from then on... I just accepted that you didn't claim those refs definitively. Please afford me the same courtesy.
  23. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    To Looking Glass: By his association with the Thaches of Spanish Town in that 1706 deed, we know beyond a doubt that Edward Thache Jr. was from there. The "right time" is the first couple of decades of the 18th century. Now, we just need to clearly establish that he is Blackbeard. In my opinion, the chances are far better than 50/50. And, as I said, future research will bear this out, I have little doubt.
  24. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    No, the info on Leslie was just a bit of info that I dug up one afternoon for kicks. Obviously, Leslie was offering what he had read on the guy. In no way was that his own opinion. I think that whoever this guy was, he had read about Johnson's viscious Blackbeard, met a Thache family on Jamaica who claimed relation to the guy and found it extraordinary that he would come from such a nice family. I would too.
  25. Blackbeard Reconsidered -a new book with new theories(?)

    Still, you have to admit that Edward Thache was in the right place at the right time, especially if Johnson had the correct intel on the guy. That increases the chances, yes? Here's what I've found on Leslie so far: St. Johns Parish Church, Barbados Rev. William and Ann Leslie left Scotland to serve as the First Rector (1653 - 1676) of St John’s Parish Church, ministering to the Parish for 23 years. This church still stands today and is still in use. The Leslies are buried in the cemetery beside it. William died 13 November 1674, many years before Ann in 1692. According to his memorial, he was the "Grandson of Fifth Laird of Kincraigie and Great Great Grandson by his Grandmother of JOHN LESLIE Eighth Baron of Balquhain." William and Ann had children: Margery, Rebecca, Isabella, Col. John and Charles Leslie. The author Charles Leslie is the son of one of these two men. On 20 July 1710, he married Rebecca Innes (Ince).